🔍 Read the full analysis: Spreadsheets And Bookkeepers: Exploring AI’s Role on ThorstenMeyerAI.com
Get the latest gadgets delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
TL;DR
U.S. bookkeeping, accounting and auditing clerk employment fell from about 2.25 million in 1988 to 1.53 million in 2025, while accountants and auditors grew from about 963,000 to 1.6 million. The source attributes the shift partly to spreadsheets and accounting software; the BLS projects further clerk declines and accountant growth through 2035, but those forecasts are not outcomes.
A November 22, 2026 report on spreadsheets and bookkeeping says U.S. employment in bookkeeping, accounting and auditing clerk roles fell to about 1.53 million in 2025, while accountant and auditor jobs rose to about 1.60 million. The figures chart a long shift as spreadsheets and accounting software automated parts of routine work; the Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) now projects further clerk declines as AI takes on tasks such as data entry, while accountant employment grows.
The report, published by ThorstenMeyerAI.com as part of its “Work After Work” series, compares BLS employment figures across several decades. It says the BLS counted about 2.25 million bookkeeping, accounting and auditing clerks in 1988, compared with about 1.53 million in 2025. Accountants and auditors rose from approximately 963,000 to 1.60 million over the same period. The figures put the two occupational groups at roughly one-to-one in 2025, versus about two bookkeepers per accountant in earlier decades.
The article links the change to technologies that reduced the time needed to record transactions and recalculate figures, while cautioning that the spreadsheet was not the only cause. Accounting software also took over much of the posting and adding work. The report points to an example from 1984: accountant Don Jackson told writer Steven Levy that a calculation that previously took him 20 hours took 15 minutes with a spreadsheet. That account illustrates a change in task time, not a measured estimate of how many jobs spreadsheets eliminated.
For the next decade, the report cites BLS projections of a 6% decline in clerk employment by 2035 and 5% growth for accountants and auditors. The BLS expects AI to take over routine tasks, including data entry, without reducing overall demand for accountants. These are forecasts, not confirmed employment outcomes; the report gives no basis for treating the projected changes as solely caused by AI.
Infographic 01 · How the spreadsheet arrived
From the abacus to VisiCalc
Machines chased bookkeeping for decades. The spreadsheet put the calculation on every desk.
Machines and the books
- Tokyo, November 1946: an American soldier with an electric calculator against a Japanese postal worker with a soroban. The abacus won four rounds out of five (Computer History Museum).
- Nuremberg, 14 February 1966: 65 tax advisers found DATEV to do their clients’ bookkeeping by computer; the first data centre had four rented IBM mainframes at DM 245,000 a month (DATEV).
- Spring 1978: Harvard Business School student Dan Bricklin imagines a calculator that redoes a ledger sheet by itself (Bricklin).
- October 1979: VisiCalc by Bricklin and Bob Frankston ships for the Apple II. The analyst Ben Rosen: “the software tail that wags (and sells) the personal computer dog.”
- Early 1983: Lotus 1-2-3 for the IBM PC; it soon replaces VisiCalc as the leading spreadsheet (Bricklin).
- 1984: more than a million spreadsheet programs a year in the US. Levy warns: even an elegant spreadsheet is “a house of cards”.
Company and personal accounts are marked as such. The 20-hours figure is one accountant’s own account, as reported by Steven Levy.
Sources: D. Bricklin, VisiCalc history; S. Levy, Harper's, November 1984; Computer History Museum; DATEV company history.
Powered by Thorsten Meyer AI
Routine Tasks and Accounting Jobs
The employment figures show why the question is not simply whether a tool “kills” a job. Routine bookkeeping work has contracted over the period covered, but the number of accountants and auditors has increased. The figures alone do not establish that spreadsheets caused the entire shift: changes in business activity, occupational classifications, software and other factors may also have contributed.
For workers and employers, the current issue is which tasks are most exposed as AI tools spread. The BLS projection cited in the report points to data entry and other routine duties as candidates for automation, while forecasting continued demand for accountants. That distinction matters to job planning and training, but the projection cannot say how quickly particular workplaces will adopt AI or what the resulting workload will be.
The scale of the remaining workforce also puts the change in perspective. About 1.53 million clerks remained employed in 2025, according to the figures cited. Automation has altered the work and the balance between occupations; it has not made bookkeeping disappear.
Products Worth Considering

Samsung 27-Inch Odyssey G5 QHD Gaming Monitor (G51F)

Apple MacBook Air 13-inch Laptop with M5 Chip, 16GB Memory, 512GB SSD, Liquid Retina Display, and 12MP Center Stage Camera (Midnight)

Sony WH-1000XM4 Wireless Noise Cancelling Headphones (Silver)
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
From Ledger Sheets to Spreadsheets
Before electronic spreadsheets, accountants often had to recalculate figures by hand when a client changed an assumption. The report traces VisiCalc to an idea Dan Bricklin had in a Harvard Business School class in 1978, and says Bricklin and programmer Bob Frankston shipped the first complete version for the Apple II on October 19, 1979. Its grid recalculated dependent figures when a user changed an input.
Spreadsheets followed earlier computerization rather than beginning it. The report says German tax-adviser cooperative DATEV was founded in 1966 to handle client bookkeeping by computer, using rented mainframes. Such systems required large machines and specialists; spreadsheets brought interactive calculations to personal computers and made what-if analysis easier for individual users.
The report’s historical figures show the occupational ratio shifting over time. Census counts cited for 1950, 1960 and 1970 put bookkeepers at about 1.9 to 2.2 per accountant. A BLS comparison of 1988 to 2000 found clerk employment declined about 6% while accountant and auditor employment rose about 13%. The article notes that the BLS had projected a small clerk increase and faster accountant growth for that earlier period, illustrating that forecasts can differ from later results.
““I would work for twenty hours. With a spreadsheet, it takes me 15 minutes.””
— Don Jackson, an accountant, quoted by Steven Levy in Harper’s in 1984
What the Forecast Cannot Show
The employment counts establish changes in the sizes of two occupational groups, but they do not isolate the effect of spreadsheets, accounting software or AI. The report does not quantify how many jobs were displaced by each technology or how many new roles were created as work changed. The 20-hour-to-15-minute example is an individual account, not a representative study.
The BLS figures for 2035 are projections, and actual outcomes may differ. The source does not detail the assumptions behind the forecasts or provide a separate estimate of AI’s impact. It is also unclear how adoption rates, employer decisions, economic conditions and future changes in accounting work will affect employment across the period.
Employment Trends Through 2035
The next measurable point will be whether actual employment data through the coming years tracks the BLS’s projected 6% clerk decline and 5% accountant growth by 2035. Those projections should be read as a baseline forecast, not a guarantee or a direct measure of AI’s contribution.
For now, the evidence in the report supports a narrower conclusion: bookkeeping and accounting work has changed alongside automation, with clerk employment down from its 1988 level and accountant employment up. More information about AI adoption, workplace tasks and later employment counts will be needed to determine how much of the next shift is attributable to AI.
Key Questions
Did spreadsheets eliminate bookkeeping jobs?
The figures show clerk employment declining over time, but they do not prove spreadsheets alone caused the decline. The report also identifies accounting software and other factors, and notes that about 1.53 million clerks were still employed in 2025.
How did U.S. clerk and accountant employment change from 1988 to 2025?
According to figures cited from the BLS, bookkeeping, accounting and auditing clerks fell from about 2.25 million in 1988 to 1.53 million in 2025. Accountants and auditors rose from about 963,000 to 1.60 million over that period.
What does the BLS project for these jobs by 2035?
The report cites BLS projections of a 6% decline in clerk employment and 5% growth for accountants and auditors by 2035. These are forecasts, not confirmed results.
Does the report show that AI will reduce accountant employment?
No. The BLS projection cited in the report expects AI to handle some routine work, such as data entry, while overall demand for accountants continues. The source does not provide a measured estimate of AI’s eventual effect on jobs.
Source: ThorstenMeyerAI.com
